The puzzle of George Orwell as essayist: final thoughts? Author: Doctor Terence Rajivan Edward Abstract. George Orwell seems to be the most well-known essayist in English of the first half of the 20th century, plausibly the most well-known essayist of that century (the artificial intelligence software Chat-GPT claiming that role in our own). But how did Orwell achieve this place, given the strength of the competition? Furthermore, Orwell's prominent place in the school curriculum is in spite of the fact that he has severe flaws by the standards of schoolmasters: his arguments have obvious but overlooked objections, likewise his definitions, and lastly his essay structures can be highly inconvenient. I consider five solutions to the puzzle of Orwell's prominence: (1) to address the objections would make the essays unreadable; (2) Orwell is a rare combination of someone by temperament suited to being the producer of bold exciting theses who scrapes a pass in the role of careful critic; (3) Orwell's position is explained by social network, by powerful backers, who-you-know-not-what-you-know; (4) Orwell at least discusses the big issues of his day, unlike some other essayists - "A Word for Autumn" by A.A. Milne! - and conveniently, all his thoughts on big topic X in one readable essay; (5) Orwell's success as essayist depends on his success as novelist. I favour a combination of (3) and (4). Draft version: version 2 (minor edits 28th October 2026, v1 this day as well) PDF available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/417026482_The_puzzle_of_George_Orwell_as_essayist_final_thoughts And: https://www.academia.edu/179771802/The_puzzle_of_George_Orwell_as_essayist_final_thoughts The puzzle When I was aged 18 I moved to the city of Manchester, in the north of England, where I enrolled in a university. I soon encountered a boy of the same age, a medical student, whom I challenged in ways I cannot now remember. They must have been challenges of the form "Can you do this?" and "And can you do this too?" but I don't recall the details. But I remember clearly his response: he repeatedly said, "I can, because I have read George Orwell." This was in 1998. I too had read Orwell, first his novel Animal Farm, two summers before, then his novel Nineteen Eighty-Four, which was on the curriculum in my final high school years and which I enjoyed writing on. But I had a schoolfriend who hated the book, a talented painter, and described Orwell as full of cliches. Also I read some essays by Orwell by my own choice, some while in high school, such as "Why I Write" and some just before coming to university. But you would not find me responding to any challenge with "I can, because I have read George Orwell"! More than 2 decades later, I saw a university student reading Orwell's "Notes on nationalism" and I asked what other English essayists he knew, from that time. He loudly declared there were so many, but did not name any! I believe Orwell is the essayist a high schoolboy is most likely to know (and even there is considerable distance between Orwell and the competition here) and probably many others too. Unfortunately, I do not have better evidence for this claim, but the popularity of Orwell as essayist is beyond reasonable doubt and hopefully that will be enough for these reflections of mine to be of interest. There were so many essayists in the first half of the 20th century. Bertrand Russell and Virginia Woolf and T.S. Eliot come to mind as famous too. For lovers of less famous literature, there is also W.E.B. DuBois, Alpha from the Plough, G.K. Chesterton, Hilaire Belloc, Max Beerbohm, Joseph Conrad, Dora Marsden, Richard Aldington, E.M. Forster, Wyndham Lewis, Laura Riding, Robert Graves; while F.H. Bradley, Sir James Frazer, C.D. Broad, and R.G. Collingwood are academics that have literary appeal too. Do you think you could do better than all of them? And when you think about it every school child had to write essays, and lots of journalists often did, and so many university men and women; while lawyers write reports on this or that. It is a puzzle then how Orwell managed to beat the entire competition and claim the premier place, the number one spot, at least famewise, among schoolboys and probably more. "He must be some genius," you say? Here I want to add significantly to the sense of puzzlement and consider some responses to the puzzle. The puzzle deepens The puzzle deepens when we recognize that Orwell does not meet schoolmasterish standards. Of James Joyce's Ulysses, Wyndham Lewis wrote, "It is an encyclopaedia of english literary technique, as well as a general-knowledge paper. The schoolmaster in Joyce is in great evidence throughout its pages." (1927: 92) Orwell seems the reverse. His essays seem to intentionally flout even the reasonable requirements of schooldays and he gives the impression of a man winking at the chalkholder at the blackboard: "I am breaking your rules and I am going to get away with that and you are going to be teaching me nevertheless," as our Prime Minister seems to wink at the general public about having no leadership contest and reversing the Brexit vote. I shall awkwardly divide the problems I find into objectionable arguments, objectionable definitions, and structural problems. (Someone somewhere surely knows all these, but I don't know of other publicly available efforts to annotate Orwell apart from my own.) 1. Objectionable arguments Orwell often makes arguments with obvious objections, or obvious to those with a bit of knowledge, yet the objections are ignored. Take his essay "Lear, Tolstoy and the Fool," in which he responds to a little-known pamphlet by Tolstoy attacking Shakespeare. Orwell is unable to believe that Tolstoy's official reasons for disliking Shakespeare are his actual reasons and guesses as what actually lies behind Tolstoy's opposition. King Lear is Tolstoy's example of Shakespeare's overrated artistry and Orwell proposes that that Tolstoy would have consciously or unconsciously identified with Lear as an old man and disliked Shakespeare's portrait of such a person: Tolstoy like Lear was someone involved in renunciation and the giving up of property. Orwell here simply ignores that Tolstoy has raised concerns about King Lear even in his much earlier and exponentially more famous novel Anna Karenina. Another obviously objectionable claim: Orwell ends his essay by saying, "Forty years later Shakespeare is still there completely unaffected, and of the attempt to demolish him nothing remains except the yellowing pages of a pamphlet which hardly anyone has read, and which would be forgotten altogether if Tolstoy had not also been the author of War and Peace and Anna Karenina." The implication seems to be that a Tolstoy who focused on writing essays, including this one, and did not write novels would be forgotten, but there are writers, including in English literature, remembered chiefly as essayists. Orwell himself earlier in his essay refers to Hazlitt; Lord Macaulay and Charles Lamb also come to mind. (There Orwell is, winking at the schoolmaster: "Yes, I know about this issue.") Sometimes an objection to Orwell is not to his arguments as such but his entire focus. In his essay "Benefit of Clergy: Some Notes on Salvador Dali" Orwell concedes that Dali has excellent draughtsmanship skills, but he is a disgusting, diseased, perverse human being. Yes, Dali seems like he can draw well to me too - to any casual observer who looks into the matter, I should think - but I would be interested in what the expert view is here and Orwell is not an art expert. He is, however, an expert in writing and he is reviewing an autobiographical text by Dali - The Secret Life of Salvador Dali - yet he never shares his views on Dali as writer: is the legendary painter any good in this medium? That's the sort of thing we want Orwell to be focusing on, but here he is curiously silent. The two essays so far deal with foreign authors: a number of Orwell's renowned essays do. In addition to essays on Tolstoy and Dali, there are essays on Ghandi, on Arthur Koestler, and on Jonathan Swift. Usually, Orwell appears to personally dislike his foreign subject matter. In the case of his review of Ghandi's autobiography, he explicitly tells us that he has never been able to like the nationalist figure and also that the essence of being human includes "that one is sometimes willing to commit sins for the sake of loyalty". Orwell the patriot, with this view of being human, reviewing foreigners, often ones he dislikes: is that not an unsuitable role for him? (Imagine a war-time period in which people are asked to volunteer to help with some surgery and you know that your hands tremble easily: would one not think, "Maybe someone else is more suited to this"?) So my section title is misleading: it is not just Orwell's arguments which are obviously objectionable, also sometimes his entire focus (away from his expertise), and even this whole role he has decided to take up given his dispositions, of reviewing foreign texts. Nevertheless, I find Orwell consistently praised for his honesty. I recall an early review in The London Mercury by poet Stephen Spender, which I don't now have access to (I crazily got rid of my copies of this journal), which presents Orwell as sincerely recording his impressions of war, even if he doesn't know much - that sincerity is his virtue. The recently deceased Oxford critic John Carey describes him as Orwell truth-teller (2014). Why? One explanation is that Orwell is honest by the standards of the background he is coming from. Another, which I am attracted to, is that Orwell went to a school famous for producing politicians, Eton, and he devoted himself to explicitly political writing and he pursues the task of literary success as some politicians would: he is less honest than average, but he and friends gets well-placed people to declare him especially honest! 2. Objectionable definitions Like just about any essayist, Orwell finds that it is sensible to define terms. Definition is a notoriously difficult task. Definitions of ordinary terms sometimes prove to have difficult-to-realize counterexamples, where intuitively we apply the term but the definition proposed says we should not or intuitively we do not apply the term but the definition says we should. Trouble with definition led Socrates to say that he knows nothing. It is unsurprising then that Orwell's definitions are not ideal, but what is surprising given his reputation of common sense is that they are obviously objectionable. Take his definition of pamphleteering in his essay on Koestler: "I mean by this the special class of literature that has arisen out of the European political struggle since the rise of Fascism." Why limit pamphleteering to European anti-fascists efforts. What about non-European efforts against Fascist or other totalitarian political systems? There seems no reason for the limitation! And what about pamphlets directed at other political ends? Orwell's "Notes on Nationalism" devotes greater space than usual to definition: to defining what he means by nationalism. He tells us, "By 'nationalism' I mean first of all the habit of assuming that human beings can be classified like insects and that whole blocks of millions or tens of millions of people can be confidently labelled 'good' or 'bad'. But secondly - and this is much more important - I mean the habit of identifying oneself with a single nation or other unit, placing it beyond good and evil and recognizing no other duty than that of advancing its interests." This overlooks nationalists who regard the deeds of their nation as evil but support them nevertheless because "They are in the interests of our nation and that is what I care about." Orwell sensibly gives Nazism as an example of a nationalist movement but were not some Nazis consciously evil (e.g. Carl Schmitt)? Anyway, Orwell joltingly goes on to say that his use of nationalism is not the same as patriotism. Presumably, he intends his use to cover patriotism but also to cover other group loyalties: loyalties to groups we do not think of as nations. But he tells us, "Nationalism, in the extended sense in which I am using the word, includes such movements and tendencies as Communism, political Catholicism, Zionism, Antisemitism, Trotskyism and Pacifism." Here a pressing question arises. Is there not a difference between "I am a communist because I think communism is the best system of government and economics for every country; if I didn't think that, I would not be" and "I am a communist because I am loyal to communism. My dad was a communist; and my grandad a communist too"? Orwell overlooks this and then his later claim that everyone, or almost everyone, is a nationalist seems vacuous - the definition is so broad as to make the claim uninteresting - because it seems to be for or against anything, which someone else somewhere is for or against too, is to be a nationalist by Orwell's standards. Although he is popular with a wide readership, sometimes Orwell's definitions seem designed to puzzle the reader. In his essay on Tolstoy on Shakespeare, he tells us, "He objects, with some justification, to the raggedness of Shakespeare's plays, the irrelevancies, the incredible plots, the exaggerated language: but what at bottom he probably most dislikes is a sort of exuberance, a tendency to take not so much a pleasure as simply an interest in the actual process of life." Surely what Orwell is looking for is a pleasure-based definition. Isn't this the contrast he is seeking to make? Tolstoy tries to be saintly, which usually involves some asceticism, and imposes other-worldly standards on literature; Shakespeare takes a pleasure, or joy, in many aspects of life, including depicting them without judgment and including a joy in words and jokes and digressive content. 3. Structure Students today in various disciplines are taught to, in their introductory paragraph, briefly specify their position on the question being addressed and the order of discussion, so that the reader does not feel lost. Orwell does not have this convention in place and, furthermore, anyone trying to summarize him will be frustrated by how he structures material sometimes. Let's turn to the Tolstoy-Shakespeare essay again. Here Orwell does actually specify some order of discussion early on, his opening sentences being: "Tolstoy's pamphlets are the least-known part of his work, and his attack on Shakespeare is not even an easy document to get hold of, at any rate in an English translation. Perhaps, therefore, it will be useful if I give a summary of the pamphlet before trying to discuss it." So he will summarize and then discuss. The early discussion reveals that Orwell has some disagreements with Tolstoy, taken at face value, taken at his word. But Orwell then tells us that he does not believe that Tolstoy's pamphlet reveals his actual reasons for opposing the high status of Shakespeare: "Certainly his dislike of Shakespeare is real enough, but the reasons for it may be different, or partly different, from what he avows; and therein lies the interest of his pamphlet. At this point one is obliged to start guessing." These words come after more than 10 paragraphs and a reader summarizing attributes this structure to the essay: "First, summarize Tolstoy; secondly, assess Tolstoy, taken at face value, expressing some disagreements; thirdly, start guessing as to the real reasons for Tolstoy's opposition to Shakespeare." Furthermore, the second sentence quoted is taken as a signal that the guessing is beginning. After all, it says, "At this point one is obliged to start guessing"! But then we encounter numerous further disagreements with Tolstoy, taken at face value! These include Tolstoy ignores the poetry of Shakespeare's language when criticizing the high status accorded to the playwright, and that the play which Tolstoy focuses on, King Lear, actually meets Tolstoy's requirement of having a dignified subject matter: it deals with renunciation. Orwell's essay "Good Bad Books" is similarly frustrating for any reader trying to summarize his thoughts. But for substance-oriented readers, these structural weaknesses are likely to seem the most superficial criticisms and I prioritize the concerns about overlooking obvious objections to argument and about faulty definitions above. Attempted solutions I consider five solutions below, settling on a combination of the third and the fourth. 1. Sensible omissions solution How did Orwell beat all the competition and get his starring place with such flaws as above? One answer is suggested to me by a poem I recently encountered. It is from a poetry collection by Marjorie Maddox entitled "In the Museum of my Daughter's Mind." In the poem, the daughter is learning the letter E. The opening lines: "Don't distract me with questions, / those extraneous detours that topple learning, / E and only E is today's lesson." The second verse, or stanza if that is the right word contains: "The enemy of schedules is curiosity, omissions / necessary for well-paced delivery". Similarly, one might propose that if Orwell addressed my objections, his essays would grow gargantuan, become correspondingly unreadable or only suitable for the few, and perhaps lose sight of their topics altogether and become preoccupied with exact definition, like Socratic dialogues. I am not convinced by this solution. It was easy enough for Orwell to avoid many of the obvious definitional concerns he raises. He could have defined nationalism, in his nonordinary sense, as loyalty to any group, whether officially a nation or not. He could have offered a pleasure-focused definition of exuberance, which makes best sense given his contrast between aspiring-saint Tolstoy and rollicking Shakespeare. He could have defined pamphleteering as a brief text of political writing devoted to opposition to or devoted to supporting some type of political regime, such as opposed to fascism. (Of course, how brief is brief? Let's say, for convenience, less than 100,000 words.) Furthermore, he could have simply dropped the dubious implication that essayists cannot survive without novels to their name too. 2. Rare combination solution A solution occurred to me which once again refers to the dialogues of Socrates. In these dialogues, or the ones textually handed down to us, a distinction is made between two roles. There is the person who makes the old, exciting proposal, inspired even. They are compared to a pregnant woman. Then there is the critic who assesses it for whether and to what extent it is true, the midwife who tries to deliver the baby. The first role is attractive for multiple reasons. One reason is that there is the prospect of greater glory. Although the description above suggests a single midwife, sometimes a person produced a thesis or argument or system of interest, and it is subject to assessment by several critics. The name of the maker becomes famous, while the critics are hardly known in comparison. (Most critics pale in fame compared to Socrates.) A second reason for being attracted to the first role, contrary even to the ancient pregnancy metaphors, is that there is less labour involved. One briefly produces the exciting thesis or argument or system and the lengthy careful critical analysis is left to others. Orwell strikes me as a person by temperament attracted to the first role, for both of the reasons above, and his essays feature numerous superficially plausible assertions in need of more careful inspection, e.g. "Autobiography is only to be trusted when it reveals something disgraceful. A man who gives a good account of himself is probably lying, since any life when viewed from the inside is simply a series of defeats"; "Kipling is almost a shameful pleasure, like the taste for cheap sweets that some people secretly carry into middle life" etc. But he officially appears to be playing the role of the critic, or closer to that role: trying to achieve a sensible and accurate "picture" of this or that subject matter. One might propose that Orwell was by temperament a person more suited to the first role, but he passes in the second role. And that is a rare combination of interest. But this seems to be an explanation of interest in Orwell amongst specialists in literature and critical thinking, not amongst the wider public. 3. Who you know, not what you know The memorable English saying, "It is who you know, not what you know" is used to capture a situation in which jobs go to people based on social connections, rather than relevant skills: an applicant's father is the boss's friend, etc. Orwell attended the famous British school Eton. In our own day, it is famous for giving rise to politicians, examples including former prime ministers David Cameron and Boris Johnson, and also current foreign secretary Ed Milliband. One might well worry that these people are not best thought of as pro whatever their official position is, Boris Johnson pro right wing and Ed Milliband pro left wing, rather what they are pro is Eton, what they do is actions in favour of team Eton. "You play the left candidate and I play right and together we do better for that school." (I cannot forget Evelyn Waugh, from his first novel, on there being a duty of a former public school boy to put another former public school boy back on his feet. "Public school" is a confusing British term for a prestigious type of private school.) Relatedly, Orwell's place in the school curriculum is ultimately owing to the influence of Eton. That is why he succeeds despite all these flaws. What can those who notice them do, given the promotion machine behind him? I agree with this explanation to an extent. I am surprised at how Orwell's glaring weaknesses and flaws are ignored by promoters. A 2009 article by an art critic for The Guardian newspaper depicts him as a sensible moderate between the reactionaries and the overenthusiastic, when responding to the paintings of Salvador Dali (Jones 2009). But he seems to have so much in common with the reactionaries. Orwell does acknowledge Dali's skill with drawing, but who doesn't? He does not demand censorship, but he describes Dali as diseased, disgusting, and perverse, suggesting a cunning have-your-cake-and-eat-it-approach: don't censor Dali and therefore qualify as a liberal still, but remove him from the mainstream and consign him to psychiatric interest only, which roughly achieves the end of the those demanding censorship anyway. This is a moderate sensible approach, is it???! Nevertheless, I am not entirely satisfied by this explanation, because it does not attend to Orwell's merits as essayist, more precisely the qualities that make him suitable as mainstream figure. 4. Conveniently discusses the big issues The puzzle as initially stated is that Orwell seems so much more successful as essayist than the competition, but how, given all this talented competition? (It was deepened by registering weaknesses in Orwell's writing, by the standards imposed on many of us.) But when one compares Orwell with various essayists, one finds that Orwell has this major advantage: he discusses the big issues of his day. Imperialism, nationalism, fascism, liberalism, Tolstoy, Gandhi, Salvador Dali, Rudyard Kipling: all discussed. I found an anthology entitled Modern Essays from 1921, before Orwell's time. A.A. Milne and Joseph Conrad and Betrand Russell are the most famous contributors, Milne famous as the author of the Winne the Pooh stories. His essay is entitled "A Word for Autumn." It is picturesquely written, opening thus: "Last night the waiter put the celery on with the cheese, and I knew that summer was indeed dead. Other signs of autumn there may be - the reddening leaf, the chill in the early-morning air, the misty evenings - but none of these comes home to me so truly." But what does one want an essayist writing for wider audiences to write on? For an essayist of today based in Britain, surely the emergence of the long-anticipated essay writing machines (Gissing 1891: chapter 8), and artificial intelligence more generally; the highly unorthodox American president Donald Trump; the coronavirus pandemic; the British vote to leave the European Union; the famous writers of the day, such as Salman Rushdie, who has lived so long under a fatwah; and climate change. "A Word for Autumn" is not what one has in mind, unless it has something to do with man-made climate change! It should also be noted that Orwell's treatment of the big issues of his day is convenient. I was recently rereading anthropologist Clifford Geertz's essay on the Balinese cockfight, which comes after the period which is my focus here. It has been much anthologized and features on many anthropology curriculums, and beyond it general social science courses. If I found one of my essays likewise anthologized, I would probably think, "Hey people like this stuff," and write more reflections on the pastime. But Geertz never did. He seems to have gathered all his thoughts into one neat essay, all conveniently in one place. I sometimes write on the sport of football. Some thoughts occur to me and I write an essay. Some thoughts later occur and I write another essay (even without much sign of interest). So it is if one is interested in a topic, or so it is likely to be! In the case of Orwell, he has his thoughts on Salvador Dali in one readable essay, his thoughts on Tolstoy against Shakespeare in another, his thoughts on Gandhi in a third, his thoughts on Kipling in a fourth, etc. At least explicitly, there is little or or no scattering of thoughts. And no changing of mind either! (Rival Wyndham Lewis wrote a book-length defence of Hitler in the early 1930s and then a book length anticipation of the end of the Hitler cult.) Orwell was an author who paid careful attention to what literature survives and flourishes, especially what literature which does not fit with the preferences of high-minded critics. It seems to me that his is a military-like project to claim the mainstream place, and one of its features is conveniently having his thoughts on big topics of the day in one place, each topic neatly covered in a readable essay. I confess I am writing this essay influenced by his practice, somewhat worried even! (Apologies pedants, but this fourth explanation is actually a combination of two factors, when scientifically one should probably specify one factor explanations and then consider combinations! Note also some of Orwell's rivals actually discuss the big issues but are from the far right: Hilaire Belloc and Wyndham Lewis. But is Orwell really a man of the left? Who knows? As suggested earlier, there is a question with Eton-educated politicians, which probably applies to its writer too: is this a man of the left and that a man of the right, or are they ultimately all team-Eton, each prominently taking a side and thereby ensuring the flourishing of the overall team? There is a saying that to not be left wing in one's youth indicates a lack of heart, to not be right wing later indicates a lack of head. I worry that Orwell examined his target audience carefully and took a left turn! It has been noted by another that Orwell's avowed political preferences do not predict his literary preferences well. Cook 1961: 125.) 5. Novel success Orwell himself suggests the following explanation for his success, at the end of his Tolstoy essay: his novels are mainstream successes, notably Animal Farm and Nineteen Eighty-Four, and his essays were able to claim a mainstream place owing to fiction-based successes. No fiction success and these nonfictions would be marginal. Perhaps, but A.A. Milne's essays are not doing well in comparison. And closer to our own day, bell hooks has made a name for herself as essayists. In the language of philosophers, fiction success seems not sufficient and not necessary. I would emphasize the third and fourth explanations above, but novel-success is perhaps an important factor too. References Carey, John. 2014. My hero: George Orwell by John Carey. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2014/mar/28/my-hero-george-orwell-john-carey Cook, Richard. 1961. George Orwell and Rudyard Kipling. Modern Fiction Studies 7(2): 125-135. Edward, Terence Rajivan. 2025. George Orwell on the definition of nationalism (and coding homework). Available at: https://philpapers.org/rec/EDWDOA-4 Edward, Terence Rajivan. 2025. Professor John Carey (1934-2025) and George Orwell as truth-teller (and coding homework appendix). Available at: https://www.academia.edu/145408655/Professor_John_Carey_1934_2025_and_George_Orwell_as_truth_teller_and_coding_homework_appendix_ (Tempted to delete this.) Edward, Terence Rajivan. 2026. The popular appeal of George Orwell as essayist. Instagram. Available at: https://www.instagram.com/p/DdbXGKaOgJz/ Edward, Terence Rajivan. 2026. On George Orwell as a rare species. Instagram. Available at: https://www.instagram.com/p/DdEJESfxoTW/ Edward, Terence Rajivan. 2026. Summaries of George Orwell essays (and some objections). Available at: https://www.academia.edu/179605996/Summaries_of_George_Orwell_essays_and_some_objections_ Geertz, Clifford. 1972. Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese cockfight. Daedalus 101 (1): 1-37. Available at: https://www.sas.rochester.edu/psc/clarke/214/Geertz72.pdf Gissing, George. 1891. New Grub Street. Available at: https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/1709/pg1709-images.html Jones, Jonathan. 2009. Why George Orwell was right about Salvador Dali. The Guardian 9th June 2009. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/jonathanjonesblog/2009/jun/09/george-orwell-art-critic-salvador-dali Lewis, Wyndham. 1927. Time and Western Man. London: Chatto and Windus. Available at: https://dn710207.ca.archive.org/0/items/timewesternmanby00lewi/timewesternmanby00lewi.pdf Lewis, Wyndham. 1931. Hitler. London: Chatto and Windus. Available at: https://ia600701.us.archive.org/32/items/adolf-hitler-archive/Hitler%20by%20Wyndham%20Lewis%20%281931%29.pdf Lewis, Wyndham. 1939. The Hitlet cult and how it will end. London: Dent. (I do not have at hand Lewis's response to Orwell in The Writer and the Absolute. I recall his describing Orwell as a man of the right who took a left turn at the last minute and that his essays along with Animal Farm and Nineteen Eighty-Four will survive.) Maddox, Marjorie. n.d. The Letter E. The Penn Review. Available at: https://www.pennreview.org/the-letter-e Milne, A.A. 1921 (date of anthologization). A Word for Autumn. In Christopher Morley (ed.), Modern Essays. New York: Harcourt, Brace and Company. Available at: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/38280/38280-h/38280-h.htm Orwell, George. 1942. Rudyard Kipling. Available at: https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/rudyard-kipling/ Orwell, George. 1944. Arthur Koestler. Available at: https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/arthur-koestler/ Orwell, George. 1944. Benefit of the Clergy: Some Notes on Salvador Dali. The Saturday Book 1944. Available at: https://www.orwell.ru/library/reviews/dali/english/e_dali (Interestingly, this much engaged-with essay is not on the Orwell foundation website list.) Orwell, George. 1945. Animal Farm. London: Secker and Warburg. Available at: https://gutenberg.net.au/ebooks01/0100011h.html Orwell, George. 1945. Good Bad Books. Tribune. Available at: https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/good-bad-books/ Orwell, George. 1945. Notes on Nationalism. Polemic. Available at: https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/notes-on-nationalism/ Orwell, George. 1946. Politics and Literature: An examination of Gulliver's Travels. Polemic 5. Available at: https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/politics-vs-literature-an-examination-of-gullivers-travels/ Orwell, George. 1947. Lear, Tolstoy and the Fool. Polemic 7. Available at: https://orwell.ru/library/essays/lear/english/e_ltf (Interestingly, this renowned essay is not on the Orwell foundation website list.) Orwell, George. 1949. Reflections on Gandhi. Partisan Review. Available at: https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/reflections-on-gandhi/ Orwell, George. 1949 (I thought it was 1948? Published on 8 June, according to various sources - my birthday!). Nineteen Eighty-Four. London: Secker and Warburg. Available at: https://dn790002.ca.archive.org/0/items/NineteenEightyFour-Novel-GeorgeOrwell/orwell1984.pdf Schmitt, Carl. 1996 (translated by George Schwab, originally 1932). The Concept of the Political. Chicago: Chicago University Press. Tolstoy, Leo. (translated by Constance Garnett). 1901 (originally 1878). Anna Karenina. Available at: https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/1399/pg1399-images.html Waugh, Evelyn. 1928. Decline and Fall. London: Chapman and Hall. Available at: https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/File:Decline_and_Fall%2C_Waugh%2C_1928.pdf