"Summaries" of T.S. Eliot's reviews for International Journal of Ethics Author: Doctor Terence Rajivan Edward (or 0161__Rajivan) Date: 26 March 2026 Review of A. Wolf's The Philosophy of Nietzsche. Eliot thinks that Nietzsche's philosophy requires his literary qualities and that his contribution to literature "owes its charm not only to the personality and wisdom of the man, but also to a claim to scientific truth." (Some will say: to attempt scientific truth for Nietzsche's topics - from human life - will involve laborious evidence in favour of what everyone intelligent knows, such as a book of evidence that cults exist. Nietzsche's books are not like this to me and I find it doubtful they are scientific by a slacker standard.) Dr Wolf claims Nietzsche did not have a philosophy of militarism. Eliot proposes that Nietzsche probably had no philosophy to do with the topic at all, merely the conflicting thoughts of a reflective person on the topic, presumably meaning by philosophy a system composed of principles or principles and inferences from them. Wolf says that Nietzsche had a theory of knowledge. Eliot again draws attention to conflicting claims by Nietzsche and says that Wolf does not convince us that he did. Eliot approves of Wolf's view that Nietzsche's view of nature is from Schopenhauer. Eliot says that, despite Wolf, he thinks Nietzsche has no consistent "policy" regarding cosmic flux. (This brief review closely resembles "in form" Matha Nussbaum on Nietzsche: where she says to be a political philosopher Nietzsche has to contribute something of value to 6 out of these 7 topics and he does not. Nussbaum seems Eliot narrowed down and done more "muscularly": quotations, lengthier arguments against, etc.) Review of Wilhelm Wundt's Elements of Folk Psychology (translated by E.L. Schaub). Eliot says this book is a classic, but a book which can be thought of as a classic upon its appearance is out of date already: it is an end rather than a beginning. No idea why he generalizes in this way: anything new and classic will surely divide readers? Eliot helpfully presents Wundt's division of stages of culture: (1) primitive, including Bushmen, Negritos, and Veddahs; (2) totemic, including the very different Australians and Iroquois, and on the blurry border Polynesians; (3) the age of heroes and gods, the beginnings of ballad and epic; (4) the development of humanity, the world's religions and empires. Eliot writes, "this method of division is partly one of stages of culture and partly one of periods of time, which tends to cast suspicion upon its scientific value." He is taking a lesson from Victorian social anthropology, I believe: some societies are temporally after others, but belong to an earlier stage. Eliot ends his review by observing that Wundt's approach ignores psychology, for example the influence of the sexual instinct on myth. There is little on religious feeling in cults. Eliot proposes that progress in this science will depend on advances in psychoanalysis. (In the middle of this demand for psychology or more of it is: Wundt neglects the aesthetic value of primitive art. More recently, Alfred Gell favours this approach: methodological philistinism, he shrewdly brands it - 1999: p. 161, italics!. I cannot access R.R. Marrett's review of Wundt from Jstor in my home, anthropologist and pleasing writer.) Review of Arthur Balfour's Theism and Humanism. The Gifford Lectures. Balfour does not argue against a professional philosopher or great philosopher, rather a popular philosophy based on biological discoveries of the 19th century. Balfour's argument is summarized thus: we find that we cannot but experience some things as beautiful and some things as good, even if there is disagreement over precisely what (and we cannot but experience the existence of an external world); science cannot account for the origin of objective value; only theism, acceptance divine power, can do this. (J.L. Mackie suggests you cannot move from individual experience of value, acknowledging diversity of what is judged valuable, to there is objective value to divine power explains it, because diversity itself gives reason to doubt objective value - the best explanation for diversity is no objective value.) Balfour denies he has a metaphysical system, but Eliot says Balfour suggests an aesthetics, an ethics and theory of knowledge. (Echoing Sidgwick on Bradley, 1876: p.545.) Balfour seeks to appeal to common premises among readers, but Eliot doubts they are there. Eliot asserts that the materialist who attributes value to art will find no inconsistency in doing so: "incongruity" is his word. Unclear why he asserts this. Eliot also asserts: "The only way to make a value negligible is to point to something of greater value…" And explains how a thoroughgoing naturalist (one who believes in no God, only material entities and qualities - my clarification) would regard value: a denial that value has any origin or cause and a Humean "no reason can be given why anything should be valued, except an appeal to another, accepted, value". Review digested too quickly! References Gell, Alfred. The Technology of Enchantment and the Enchantment of Technology. In Gell (edited by Eric Hirsch), 1999. The Art of Anthropology. Essays and Diagrams. Oxford: Berg. Available at: https://monoskop.org/images/4/48/Gell_Alfred_The_Art_of_Anthropology_Essays_and_Digrams_1999.pdf Eliot, T. Stears. January 1916. Review of Theism and Humanism by A. J. Balfour Review by: International Journal of Ethics Vol. 26, No. 2 (Jan., 1916), pp. 284- 289 Eliot, T. Stearns. April 1916. Review of The Philosophy of Nietzsche by A. Wolf. International Journal of Ethics Vol. 26, No. 3: pp. 426- 427. Available at uk.jstor.org Eliot, T. Stearns. 1917. Review of Elements of Folk Psychology by Wilhelm Wundt, translated by E.L. Schaub. International Journal of Ethics Vol. 27, No. 2: pp. 252-254. Available at uk.jstor.org Eliot, T.S. 1949. From Poe to Valéry. The Hudson Review 2(3): 327-342. (Didn't refer to it. Says Poe lacks system!) Mackie, John Leslie. 1977. Ethics: Inventing Right and Wrong. New York: Penguin Books. See the first chapter. Available at: https://spot.colorado.edu/~heathwoo/readings/mackie.pdf Nussbaum, Martha. 1997. Is Nietzsche a political thinker? International Journal of Philosophical Studies 5 (1):1 – 13. (She says she will be polemical like Nietzsche himself, but academics don't publish polemics normally - maybe the Journal of Cristiano Ronaldo Studies does?... Is there some code based on similar journal titles, which allows this?) Sigwick, Henry. 1876. Review of Ethical Studies, by F. H. Bradley. Mind 1(4): 545-549. Available on jstor.org Strathern, Marilyn. (With comments, including by I.C. Jarvie) 1987. Out of Context: The Persuasive Fictions of Anthropology. Current Anthropology 28 (3): 251-281. (I didn't refer to this, but it discusses Frazer as familiar from the start. P.258.)